Skip to main content

Who pays broker fees for a rental?

Archive topic 2026
A rental owner and leasing agent reviewing an agreement at an office table

The short answer

Who pays a broker or leasing agent usually depends on who hired them and what the written agreement says. New York City and Massachusetts now bar passing a landlord's broker fee on to the renter. Settle fee terms in writing before anyone starts work.

On this page

Who a broker works for

A broker or leasing agent can represent the landlord, the renter or, in some deals, both. A landlord's agent markets the unit, shows it and handles applications for the owner. A renter's agent searches for a home on a renter's behalf. A dual agent acts for both sides of the same deal.

Knowing who hired the agent tells you most of what you need about who should pay, and the new local laws below are built on that idea.

Common fee arrangements

Leasing fees are usually set by agreement. Common arrangements include a one-time leasing fee the landlord pays when a lease is signed, a fee a renter pays to an agent the renter hired, and an ongoing management fee that includes leasing work. Whatever the arrangement, the written agreement should say who pays, how much, when the fee is earned and what happens if the renter leaves early.

New York City: the FARE Act

New York City's Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses (FARE) Act, Local Law 119 of 2024, took effect on June 11, 2025. According to the city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP):

  • A broker who represents the landlord, including a listing agent, may not charge the renter a fee. An agent who publishes a listing is presumed to have the landlord's permission.
  • Renters may still hire their own broker and pay that broker. No one may make a rental depend on hiring a broker, including a dual agent.
  • Listings must disclose every fee a renter must pay, clearly and conspicuously.
  • Before the lease is signed, the landlord or agent must give the renter an itemized written disclosure of required fees to sign, keep the signed copy for three years and give the renter a copy.
  • A landlord is liable if its agent charges a renter a fee to rent the apartment. DCWP can seek civil penalties and restitution, and renters can sue in civil court.

The law does not bar charging for background and credit checks. New York State limits that charge to the actual cost or $20, whichever is less (N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 238-a(1)).

Massachusetts

Since August 1, 2025, Massachusetts law says a fee for finding rental housing shall only be paid by the party, landlord or tenant, who originally engaged and entered into a contract with the licensed broker or salesperson (Mass. G.L. c. 112, § 87DDD½). A landlord who hires a broker pays that broker, and a renter who hires their own broker pays that one.

The rule turns on who signed the contract with the broker, so keep a copy of every brokerage agreement with the lease file.

Everywhere else: read the agreement and local rules

Outside these places, check your state and city rules before you agree to anything, then put the terms in writing:

  • Who hired the broker and who pays.
  • The fee amount and how it is calculated.
  • When the fee is earned: at signing, at move-in or after the first rent payment.
  • Whether any fee is refunded if the renter never moves in or leaves early.
  • What the agent may promise or charge renters on your behalf.

If a renter will owe any fee, disclose it in the listing and before they apply, so the total cost to move in is clear from the start.

Questions to ask before hiring a leasing agent

  • Is the agent licensed where the property is, and who is the supervising broker?
  • Which tasks are included: pricing, photos, listing, showings, applications, screening, the lease and move-in?
  • Who approves the renter, and who signs the lease?
  • How and when will the agent report inquiries, showings and applications to you?
  • What does the agent do if a renter asks for an accommodation or a fee waiver?

Your agent's ads are your concern too

The Fair Housing Act's advertising ban reaches anyone who makes, prints or publishes, or causes to be made, printed or published, a rental notice, statement or ad that indicates a preference, limitation or discrimination based on a protected characteristic (42 U.S.C. § 3604(c)). Give your agent your written screening criteria and fee terms, and read the listing text before it goes live.

Leasing on your own

Many owners of a few rentals do the leasing work themselves: the listing, inquiries, showings, applications and the lease. That avoids a leasing fee, but it takes time during each vacancy and a consistent process to stay within fair housing rules. If you hire help, the questions above apply whether the agent works for a fee per lease or as part of full management.

How Rentari helps

If you lease on your own, Rentari listings syndicate to listing sites, the leasing inbox keeps leads together, and you can schedule showings, take online rental applications and send the lease for e-signature from one place.

Sources and further reading

Common questions

Can a New York City landlord pass its broker's fee to the renter?

No. Under the FARE Act, a broker who represents the landlord may not charge the renter, and the landlord is liable if its agent does.

Can a renter in New York City still pay a broker?

Yes, when the renter chooses to hire their own broker. No one may make renting an apartment depend on hiring a broker.

Does the FARE Act stop landlords from charging for a credit check?

No. New York State law still allows a background and credit check charge of the actual cost or $20, whichever is less.

Who pays the broker in Massachusetts?

Since August 1, 2025, the party that originally engaged and contracted with the licensed broker or salesperson, whether that is the landlord or the tenant.

Archive years group longstanding rental topics. This Rentari guide was published on 2026-11-14.

The Rentari team writes and updates this guide. Examples illustrate decisions and do not describe customer results. This is general education. Confirm the rules and treatment for your property with a qualified local professional. Found an error or an unclear step? Send a correction with a link to this page and the wording you’d change.